Hi Aaron,
Thanks for bringing this article to our attention and thanks Scott for stepping in, it’s not controversial at all Aaron but great for discussion and conversation.
I would totally agree with everything Scott has written. This article does not draw any firm conclusions and is perhaps more cautionary. I think what the article is really trying to highlight is ensuring that endurance athletes are eating enough to fuel their requirements as the issue of relative energy deficiency in sport has been brought to everyone’s attention recently. If fasted sessions are added in, this then further increases the risks of creating an undesirable energy deficit and insufficient fuelling.
I think this has to be taken in a case by case context regardless of sex in terms of when to recommend fasted training (as Scott explains). What I have seen practically in ultra endurance athletes and uphill athlete clients is that regardless of fasted sessions it is about making sure with an increase in training load, dietary intake is matched to support fuelling, training adaptations, recovery and health. When fasted training sessions are added in they do further increase the stress on the body (i.e. immune system, increase in muscle damage, further rise in the stress hormone cortisol) so it is key that appropriate recovery is added in (in terms of training and diet) and the ‘athlete’ meets daily energy and nutrient demands, when this is achieved the risks are then minimal.
I am yet to see any evidence on the detrimental impact of fasted training sessions and female athletes (when carried out safely and as advised with a supporting dietary intake that helps to meet energy demands), I think more research is being carried out on female athletes but I think the risks are there for men as well as in women.
The other occurrence I am noticing more and more with athletes is that fasting days are being carried out in addition to fasted training sessions, and this I would advise against. Evidence has shown that when we spend extended periods of time in a negative energy state this over a period of time can start to have a negative impact on health and performance (such as those detriments the article highlights).
My advice would be when carrying out fasted sessions appropriately it is really vital that you include a recovery meal/snack within 30-60mins of the fasted session (that includes carbohydrate and protein), to then ensure daily energy requirements are met via meals/snacks for the rest of that day to support recovery, training adaptations and health.
It is also about good education around fasted training sessions and if the correct guidance is provided for athletes around fasting training then I think as Scott highlights, we know it is beneficial to endurance performance and health markers.
Fasted training will have long term risks (in both men and women) if not followed appropriately and if insufficient dietary intake is not eaten over a period of time. Fasted training will also hold risks if that individual who is carrying out the fasted sessions is already compromised in terms of other confounding issues e.g. RED-S, an existing already low body fat/under weight, significant weight loss, over training, illness, or pre-existing history of disordered eating /eating disorders, menstrual dysfunction.
Rebecca